Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

Tax incentives target poor neighborhoods but leave communities behind

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — Lawmakers often tout pro-gentrification tax incentives such as the new federal “opportunity zone” tax incentive – the tax break offered to developers in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 – as tools to promote capital investment in poor neighborhoods.

While they traditionally enjoy significant bipartisan support, place-based tax incentives are often disappointing to anti-poverty advocates. But what many advocates regard as a flaw of such incentives – specifically, the lack of safeguards to protect poor communities – may actually be a feature of the policy, says a new paper from a University of Illinois expert who studies the intersection of tax law and social policy.

The development of place-based investment tax incentives can be explained as a predictable result of the “pro-gentrification legal, business and political environment that produced them,” said Michelle D. Layser, a professor of law at Illinois.

“Public discussion about tax incentives to encourage investment in low-income areas often comes from two perspectives: pro-growth and anti-poverty,” Layser said. “The pro-growth perspective argues that it’s going to spur investment, which will be good for business, economic growth and jobs – all the things we like to see when we’re thinking about the economy.

“And traditionally, these kinds of incentives have garnered a lot of support across the political spectrum and have been fairly popular because they’re viewed as having this double dividend: economic growth and easing the burden of poverty.”

But the notion that such tax incentives have been designed to alleviate poverty has “always been misguided,” Layser said.

“None of these laws have been designed in a way in which we should expect that they would help poor communities,” she said. “This is not to say that they couldn’t be designed with communities in mind. They absolutely could be. But the political, economic and legal environment under which these laws have been crafted and come to be used over time has not been conducive to such pro-community goals.”

Opportunity zones, for example, allow state governors to designate specific low-income areas for certain tax-subsidized financing. But many of the projects that are prioritized under the current system don’t have the pre-existing community in mind.

“They have in mind a wealthier demographic – people who are going to come into that community, spend money and live in the fancy new condos and turn this neighborhood that was once viewed as economically declining into a new booming pocket of tax revenues,” Layser said.

Community advocacy groups may feel misled by such policies because “they feel that a lot of this money is going toward gentrifying areas, and this law is not meaningfully designed to raise people out of poverty or help poor communities – that it potentially opens the door to trample all over them,” Layser said.

“The rhetoric of late has really shifted on opportunity zones,” she said. “Many commentators are skeptical. But really, this isn’t new. Tax incentives to invest in poor areas have never been designed to advance the needs of poor communities, and opportunity zones are just another chapter in a much longer story.”

Anti-poverty goals may be advanced more effectively through community-oriented investment tax incentives, which would confer power to community stakeholders, link place to community and incorporate a system for monitoring outcomes.

But such incentives are “rare under current law,” Layser said.

“One question that always comes up is, ‘How can you invest in a community without gentrifying it? Isn’t it inevitable?’ My answer to that is not necessarily,” she said. “We need to spend more time talking to people in poor communities and finding out what they need. Responding to those needs can improve their quality of life and improve their experience of their environment – way more than a new condo building ever would.”

The paper provides a roadmap for designing community-oriented investment tax incentives that employ “mental mapping techniques to inform the tax incentive designs” and pilot programs of community-oriented investment tax incentives that would enable researchers to study their impact and evaluate their potential as large-scale anti-poverty programs.

“It could turn out that what poor areas really need are run-of-the-mill chain grocery stores – not coffee shops, high-end grocery stores or new high-rise condo developments,” she said. “And you would only find that out by talking to the people who live in that community.”

The paper will be published in the Wisconsin Law Review.

Editor’s notes: To contact Michelle Layser, call 217-300-7973; email mlayser@illinois.edu.

The paper “The pro-gentrification origins of place-based investment tax incentives and a path toward community oriented reform” is available online.

Read Next

Health and medicine Life sciences Veterinary medicine Two men in a lab. The seated man holds a hologram projection of a brain.

Mutation increases enzyme in mouse brains linked to schizophrenia behaviors

Researchers found a key role for an enzyme regulating glycine in the brain while investigating a rare genetic mutation found in two patients with schizophrenia.

Honors A photo collage featuring all three Sloan Fellowship awardees.

Three Illinois professors named Sloan Research Fellows

Three Illinois scientists are among 126 recipients of the 2025 Sloan Research Fellowships from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. According to the foundation, the awardees represent “the very best of early-career science, embodying the creativity, ambition, and rigor that drive discovery forward.” This year’s Illinois recipients are chemistry professors Angad Mehta and Lisa Olshansky, and materials science and engineering professor Yingjie Zhang.

Life sciences Graphic with the title "42nd Insect Fear Film Festival" in a scary font and with a picture of a tarantula.

Insect Fear Film Festival to feature ‘hairy, scary’ tarantulas

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — The 2025 Insect Fear Film Festival at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign will feature “Tarantulas: Hairy, Scary Spiders” as its theme and a Hollywood bug wrangler who works with the 8-legged creatures as a special guest. The festival, which is hosted by the Entomology Graduate Student Association and is in its 42nd […]

Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

507 E. Green St
MC-426
Champaign, IL 61820

Email: stratcom@illinois.edu

Phone (217) 333-5010