Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

Role of workers in national emergencies should be clarified, scholar says

In a forthcoming paper, Michael H. LeRoy, a professor in the Institute of Labor and Industrial Relations and in the College of Law, simulated a case of a workplace that was contaminated by radiation, prompting fearful workers to ignore orders to perform essential duties.

In a forthcoming paper, Michael H. LeRoy, a professor in the Institute of Labor and Industrial Relations and in the College of Law, simulated a case of a workplace that was contaminated by radiation, prompting fearful workers to ignore orders to perform essential duties.

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. – Updating and clarifying the role of civilian workers in times of national emergencies is a pressing need that would improve homeland security, a University of Illinois legal scholar says.

In a forthcoming paper, Michael H. LeRoy, a professor in the Institute of Labor and Industrial Relations and in the College of Law, simulated a case of a workplace that was contaminated by radiation, prompting fearful workers to ignore orders to perform essential duties.

He pointed out that neither the president nor Congress has tackled the legal ramifications of forcing civilians to perform tasks during a terrorist attack, flu pandemic, catastrophic accident or destructive act of nature.

The president can declare a national emergency during a labor dispute under the 1948 Taft-Hartley Act and seek an 80-day back-to-work injunction. But this legal tool is only available in the case of private-sector jobs. “Thus,” LeRoy wrote, “the U.S. has limited jurisdiction over critical jobs in a national emergency work stoppage.”

State and local governments have authority over the employment practices of many public workers, including police, firefighters and sanitation workers.

New Orleans took no legal action to force police officers to continue working in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in part because the city was too devastated for the courts to remain open. An 1878 law, the Posse Comitatus Act, restricts the use of federal troops in domestic crises, which limited the potential deployment of U.S. armed forces in response to Katrina.

There are other legal hurdles that “have new relevance as the U.S. grapples with national emergencies,” according to LeRoy.

These include a constitutional ban on involuntary servitude (13th Amendment) and the right of employees to refuse to work on safety and health grounds (1970 Occupational Safety and Health Act).

“A report by Congress worries that avian flu will cause sick and frightened medical personnel to stay away from work, jeopardizing a coherent response to a crisis,” he wrote.

In his paper, the Illinois scholar recommends that Congress clarify the laws on requiring civilians, such as emergency doctors, nurses, police, pharmaceutical plant workers and longshoremen, to work under conditions that could expose them to life-threatening hazards.

Without legislative action, a future crisis will have to be resolved by the courts, which historically have overridden individual rights in the name of public welfare. Without a more nuanced labor policy, the nation risks being unprepared in a major crisis, while individual workers risk being unduly exposed to extraordinary risks.

His paper, forthcoming in the Berkeley Journal of Employment & Labor Law, is titled, “Compulsory Labor in a National Emergency: Public Service or Involuntary Servitude? The Case of Crippled Ports.”

Read Next

Humanities Diptych image with book cover of "The New Internationals" and a headshot of English professor David Wright Faladé

English professor’s novel tells of love triangle in post-WWII Paris, based on his family history

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — A new novel by University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign English professor David Wright Faladé tells the story of three people in a love triangle in post-World War II Paris. The characters in “The New Internationals” — a young French woman who has survived the Holocaust, a university student from West Africa and a […]

Life sciences Portrait of the research team posing together.

Minecraft players can now explore whole cells and their contents

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — Scientists have translated nanoscale experimental and computational data into precise 3D representations of bacteria, yeast and human epithelial, breast and breast cancer cells in Minecraft, a video game that allows players to explore, build and manipulate structures in three dimensions. The innovation will allow researchers and students of all ages to navigate […]

Arts Photo of seven dancers onstage wearing blue tops and orange or yellow flowing skirts. The backdrop is a Persian design.

February Dance includes works experimenting with live music, technology and a ‘sneaker ballet’

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — The dance department at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign will present February Dance 2025: Fast Forward this week at Krannert Center for the Performing Arts. February Dance will be one of the first performances in the newly renovated Colwell Playhouse Theatre since its reopening. The performances are Jan. 30-Feb. 1. Dance professor […]

Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

507 E. Green St
MC-426
Champaign, IL 61820

Email: stratcom@illinois.edu

Phone (217) 333-5010