Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

Proposed bank tax targets revenge, not reform, economist says

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. – A proposed $90 billion tax on the nation’s largest banks is more about revenge than regulation, a University of Illinois banking expert says.

Charles Kahn, an economist and the head of the U. of I. finance department, says the Obama administration’s tax plan is flawed as a long-term safeguard against risk-taking by banks that fueled the nation’s deepest economic crisis since the Great Depression.

But he says the call for a temporary, 10-year tax is “astute politics” that would feed the public’s thirst to punish Wall Street without imposing a permanent levy that could ultimately damage the financial system.

“Perhaps the political logic is this: If we make the fat cats howl loud enough, then public opinion will be assuaged,” Kahn said. “The pound of flesh will have been extracted and financial institutions can return to normal, without subjecting the system to a new, overarching tax structure.”

“In other words, it’s a balancing act,” he said. “How do you stage the maximum of perceived revenge with the minimum of damage to the financial system itself?”

A tax is appealing to outraged Americans who want to punish banks for their role in the economic meltdown, the taxpayer-supported bailouts that followed and the hefty pay handed to bank executives as other workers struggled to make ends meet, he said.

“All of these explanations will be satisfying to voters,” Kahn said. “But in reality they will be poor justifications of any permanent program.”

A tax that seeks to reimburse taxpayers is pointless, he says, because banks that received bailout money will likely reimburse the government for direct costs anyway and any indirect costs are impossible to link to one institution over another.

Kahn also says imposing a tax to limit executive compensation could be counterproductive in a financial industry that operates globally. While banks would likely absorb the taxes in the short run, businesses could move off shore in the long run.

He questions the effectiveness of collectively punishing the financial industry after the fact. He also worries that the move could set a dangerous precedent if approved by Congress, leading to future taxes for behavior that merely runs afoul of lawmakers rather than being clearly bad for the economy.

“This tax cannot successfully discriminate between institutions that caused the crisis and institutions that ameliorated the crisis,” Kahn said. “Indeed, on the same grounds, you might as well tax members of Congress for their role in the crisis.”

He says regulators around the world are examining taxes and fees to discourage risk-taking that could net another financial meltdown, but face a host of serious concerns.

If taxes are imposed unevenly across countries, institutions will merely move, Kahn said. A tax imposed based on businesses’ labels – such as banks, intermediaries or hedge funds – will simply lead those institutions to change their labels.

“Given the difficulties, it’s reasonable to ask whether regulators should be trying so hard to adjust financial institutions’ incentives in these ways, or whether they should instead focus on how to make crises less damaging when they do arise,” he said.

Read Next

Health and medicine Dr. Timothy Fan, left, sits in a consulting room with the pet owner. Between them stands the dog, who is looking off toward Fan.

How are veterinarians advancing cancer research in dogs, people?

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — People are beginning to realize that dogs share a lot more with humans than just their homes and habits. Some spontaneously occurring cancers in dogs are genetically very similar to those in people and respond to treatment in similar ways. This means inventive new treatments in dogs, when effective, may also be […]

Honors From left, individuals awarded the 2025 Campus Awards for Excellence in Public Engagement are Antoinette Burton, director of the Humanities Research Institute; Ariana Mizan, undergraduate student in strategy, innovation and entrepreneurship; Lee Ragsdale, the reentry resource program director for the Education Justice Project; and Ananya Yammanuru, a graduate student in computer science. Photos provided.

Awards recognize excellence in public engagement

The 2025 Campus Awards for Excellence in Public Engagement were recently awarded to faculty, staff and community members who address critical societal issues.

Uncategorized Portrait of the researchers standing outside in front of a grove of trees.

Study links influenza A viral infection to microbiome, brain gene expression changes

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — In a study of newborn piglets, infection with influenza A was associated with disruptions in the piglets’ nasal and gut microbiomes and with potentially detrimental changes in gene activity in the hippocampus, a brain structure that plays a central role in learning and memory. Maternal vaccination against the virus during pregnancy appeared […]

Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

507 E. Green St
MC-426
Champaign, IL 61820

Email: stratcom@illinois.edu

Phone (217) 333-5010