Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

‘Positive illusions’ in romantic relationships

The makeups and breakups of celebrity marriages are endlessly scrutinized in the entertainment media. When stories of infidelity or criminal conduct emerge, such as the allegations of sexual assault currently beleaguering comedian Bill Cosby, the focus inevitably turns to the person’s spouse, with speculation about the wronged spouse’s awareness of their partner’s activities outside the marriage.

Brian Ogolsky, a professor of human development and family studies at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, studies romantic relationships. Ogolsky spoke recently with News Bureau education editor Sharita Forrest about the dynamics of romantic relationships and the role that illusions play in promoting domestic bliss.

Some researchers have suggested that couples who have higher levels of positive illusions about their partners and relationships are happier and their relationships last longer. Doesn’t that run counter to popular wisdom that accurate understanding of each other’s attributes and shortcomings is the key to happiness?

There is fairly robust research about positive illusions, which suggests that the couples who do best engage in these illusory beliefs. They think, on average, that they and their partner are better individuals and relational partners than others. Those illusions have extremely positive benefits for the relationship, such as higher satisfaction, fewer conflicts and less doubt about the relationship’s future.

In addition, the people who believe their relationships are more likely to last – and are better-than-average – are generally more satisfied.

But what researchers find when we look at relationships is that “average” is “average.” That is, despite thoughts to the contrary, some relationships may be just average or even below average, in comparison with others.

It’s human nature to believe we are unique and our relationships are destined for success. These beliefs make us feel that there’s a good reason to live life and stay with our partners. It’s a self-protective mechanism.

Do we then filter out negative information that challenges those beliefs, even when there’s overwhelming evidence that our relationship or partner is not exceptional?

Illusory beliefs promote satisfaction, which discourages us from thinking we’d be more satisfied single or with another person, so we’re more likely to continue in the relationship that we’re in than to break up.

Your most recent research found that dating couples distorted their memories of their relationships, recalling them as being more positive or less positive, depending upon whether they currently intended to marry. Do couples who are dating have better insight or objectivity into the health of their relationships than people who have been married a long time?

We know that married couples in general follow the pattern of developmental change: When recalling the distant past, they give themselves room for growth by “remembering” themselves as being less satisfied or less committed to their partner in the past. This allows them to appear as if they’ve grown, perhaps more than they actually have.

Unmarried couples whose stage of involvement – casually dating, seriously dating or engaged – didn’t change during our nine-month study showed a similar pattern to the married folks.

However, couples who were moving toward a deeper level of commitment showed a nearly perfect correspondence between how they reported their commitment to their relationship currently and retrospectively.

What we surmise is going on there is that their goal is to be as accurate as possible to avoid making a poor decision when the stakes are high.

The couples whose relationships regressed – for example, they broke up or broke up and reunited – did something very different. They recalled themselves as being moderately committed over the entire course of the study. But when we asked them to graph their commitment trajectory each month, it actually went steeply downward.

They were doing what we call “amplification” – effectively deluding themselves into believing their level of commitment was stable, when it was actually tapering off. We controlled for the length of relationship, and whether couples were living together or not, and those factors didn’t seem to matter at all.

We believe that these distortions about their past level of commitment allow people to justify remaining in the relationship – even when they’re not that happy – and avoid cognitive dissonance.

 

Read Next

Health and medicine Life sciences Veterinary medicine Two men in a lab. The seated man holds a hologram projection of a brain.

Mutation increases enzyme in mouse brains linked to schizophrenia behaviors

Researchers found a key role for an enzyme regulating glycine in the brain while investigating a rare genetic mutation found in two patients with schizophrenia.

Honors A photo collage featuring all three Sloan Fellowship awardees.

Three Illinois professors named Sloan Research Fellows

Three Illinois scientists are among 126 recipients of the 2025 Sloan Research Fellowships from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. According to the foundation, the awardees represent “the very best of early-career science, embodying the creativity, ambition, and rigor that drive discovery forward.” This year’s Illinois recipients are chemistry professors Angad Mehta and Lisa Olshansky, and materials science and engineering professor Yingjie Zhang.

Life sciences Graphic with the title "42nd Insect Fear Film Festival" in a scary font and with a picture of a tarantula.

Insect Fear Film Festival to feature ‘hairy, scary’ tarantulas

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — The 2025 Insect Fear Film Festival at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign will feature “Tarantulas: Hairy, Scary Spiders” as its theme and a Hollywood bug wrangler who works with the 8-legged creatures as a special guest. The festival, which is hosted by the Entomology Graduate Student Association and is in its 42nd […]

Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

507 E. Green St
MC-426
Champaign, IL 61820

Email: stratcom@illinois.edu

Phone (217) 333-5010