Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

Gun rights still fuzzy despite high court ruling, U. of I. expert says

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. – The long-debated question over the right to bear arms remains unsettled despite a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that extends Second Amendment guarantees to state and local gun-control laws, a University of Illinois legal expert says.

Lawrence Solum says Monday’s 5-4 decision ruled only that constitutional protections trump far-reaching gun-control measures, such as a handgun ban enacted by the city of Chicago.

But he says the ruling provides no guidance to lower courts on how to handle challenges to state and local laws that are less restrictive than handgun bans, such as regulating commercial sale of firearms or prohibiting possession of guns by felons or the mentally ill.

“It seems almost certain that the lower federal courts will apply a variety of inconsistent standards,” said Solum, a constitutional law expert. “That means that the Second Amendment will surely return to the Supreme Court in the next two or three years as these cases work their way through the system.”

He says the high court ruling was expected, coming almost exactly two years after another 5-4 ruling that the Second Amendment protects an individual right to own guns in the District of Columbia, where the federal government has ultimate authority over laws.

Monday’s ruling extends that protection to overreaching laws imposed by state and local governments.

But even the majority was divided in its rationale behind the ruling, said Solum, who also is a professor of philosophy at the U. of I.

Four of the five justices in the majority based their ruling on the due process clause of the 14th Amendment, a post-Civil War amendment that has been used to make most of the Bill of Rights applicable to the states, he said.

Associate Justice Clarence Thomas, the crucial fifth vote, rejected that theory, instead concluding that the Second Amendment applies to states under the 14th Amendment’s “privileges and immunities” clause.

Many constitutional scholars had hoped the court would revise its approach on applying constitutional protections to states by siding with the “privileges and immunities” clause, which says “no state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States.”

There is evidence that the clause was written specifically for firearm rights, to allow freed slaves to have guns to defend themselves, according to research by legal historians.

Solum says Thomas’ understanding of the legal history appears to be heavily influenced by the work of legal scholar Kurt Lash, who will join the U. of I. College of Law this summer.

“Although the bottom line was no surprise, there are some interesting and even surprising wrinkles and twists produced by the five separate opinions written by the justices,” Solum said.

Read Next

Life sciences Portrait of the research team posing together.

Minecraft players can now explore whole cells and their contents

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — Scientists have translated nanoscale experimental and computational data into precise 3D representations of bacteria, yeast and human epithelial, breast and breast cancer cells in Minecraft, a video game that allows players to explore, build and manipulate structures in three dimensions. The innovation will allow researchers and students of all ages to navigate […]

Arts Photo of seven dancers onstage wearing blue tops and orange or yellow flowing skirts. The backdrop is a Persian design.

February Dance includes works experimenting with live music, technology and a ‘sneaker ballet’

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — The dance department at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign will present February Dance 2025: Fast Forward this week at Krannert Center for the Performing Arts. February Dance will be one of the first performances in the newly renovated Colwell Playhouse Theatre since its reopening. The performances are Jan. 30-Feb. 1. Dance professor […]

Honors portraits of four Illinois researchers

Four Illinois researchers receive Presidential Early Career Award

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. — Four researchers at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign were named recipients of the Presidential Early Career Award for Scientists and Engineers, the highest honor bestowed by the U.S. government on young professionals at the outset of their independent research careers. The winners this year are health and kinesiology professor Marni Boppart, physics professor Barry Bradlyn, chemical and biomolecular engineering professor Ying […]

Strategic Communications and Marketing News Bureau

507 E. Green St
MC-426
Champaign, IL 61820

Email: stratcom@illinois.edu

Phone (217) 333-5010